28 responses to “Nate Marshall McGee”

  1. Honestly? This dude can sing ok, but I think he’ll have an absolute meltdown before he can get anywhere.

  2. Hey I used to sing with him all the time he knows what to do he will get it there and work his butt off go buddy go we are all routing for you back home much love man !!!

  3. Oh my gosh. When I watched his audition, I automatically knew that he was going to win, for sure! I love him! :)

  4. Nates amazing! Chelsea, Sammi, and I are rooting for you up in the Falls! Your gunna make it all the way Nate! ♥

    -Kait from Reality Check

  5. This whiny prima donna definitely ranks in the Top 10 of most annoying American Idol contestants. Can’t wait to see him go. He won’t make it out of the semi-finals. And we won’t hear a peep out of him again. Maybe he can get a job at Claire’s Boutique and then he can get the employee discount to grow his headband collection.

  6. He is pretty disgusting and i think his singing sucks. hope i’m not out of line.

  7. I feel sorry for the people who are around you in general. Drama! Drama! Drama! Drama! Drama! But as soon as you are asked to sing, WOW! Totally confident and talented while singing! Try to be that guy all the time!!!! PLEASE!

  8. LOOOOOVE HIM!!!!!!!!..and he’s from Malone…I love malone.

  9. Nate can seriously sing.
    he’s doing soo good.

    everyone in reality is rooting for you!!
    nate we love you.
    good luck.

  10. Despite what the producers have shown, Nate is not the one that starts the drama. Yes, he reacts to the drama, but wouldn’t you too if you had the life that he had?
    Nate is a REALLY good kid. I am so happy that Idol FINALLY painted him in a different light the other night. He has a huge heart and wants nothing but the best for the people he surrounds himself with. We have to all band together and make sure he gets through his week!!

    GO NATE GO!!

    • He’s awesome…a little dramatic, yes, but who cares? All of the people who like TATIANA think HE’S dramatic? Psh! Nate’s awesome, he’s got my vote.

  11. Given the tragic plane crash in Buffalo, the people of Northern New York may need some good news.
    Through his singing, Nate may draw an audience not only from New York and Vermont, but from southern Quebec and Montreal. He needs all the votes he can get. Hopefully, his singing and story are good enough to draw votes from the entire AI viewship.
    I was born and raised in Malone too.

    • What does a plane crash in Buffalo have to do with Northern NY? Buffalo AIN’T EVEN CLOSE!! Buffalo is just as far from Northern NY as NY City! YES PEOPLE!! THERE IS LIFE NORTH OF ALBANY!! And one of our own is a top contender for AMERICAN IDOL!!

      • Bob, believe it or not, 99% of American Idol voters do not know that Buffalo is not part of Northern NY, or care. I was just trying to give one more reason to vote for Nate, that’s all.

  12. I think that Bob Mould, another Malone native and member of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, should consider lobbying for Nate.

  13. Unlike most, I actually know Nate Marshall as we went to high school together and I spent time with him this past summer at our local fair, which by the way is a blast. Nate has been through so much crap in his life, and I think no one deserves this more than he does. Yes, Nate can be a drama queen at times, but it’s how he has managed to survive all these years and I say, “You go GIRL!” Personally it’s nice to see somebody representing the North Country in a competition as popular as this one, because maybe now it will bring some comradery to our neck of the woods. I now know that American Idol is NOT fake, because Nate crying all the time is the real deal, but I don’t care, it’s a singing competition and I’m sure he will go far. He certainly does have the potential to be one of the greats, I mean William Hung is popular, right?

    Good luck Nate,
    Roberto Leabo

    • LOL! ROBERT! YESSS!! I was there too. (County Fair)
      Nate can be dramatic, but he’s really not that dramatic ALL the time. He deserves it. He’s really good!

    • hi roberto. i am trying to find nathaniels new address in burlington vermont so that i can send him a check. please can you help me? thanks tommy blix@verizonmail.com

  14. I THINK NATE IS A WONDERFUL GREAT SPIRIT PERSON
    AMERICAN IDOL WILL BE MISSING OUT ON THIS MAN IF YOU VOTE HIM OFF GIVE HIM A CHANCE AND SIMON HE WILL GIVE YOU 110 PERCENT IN RETURN.
    HE MAY EVEN BYPASS CARRIE UNDERWOOD DONT JUGDE PEOPLE BY WHAT THEY WEAR MAYBE THATS ALL HE HAS .MALONE IS SMALL AND
    WE DONT PRIDE OURSELF ON MATERAL THINGS JUST GOOD OLD FUN
    AND GOOD TIMES. PLEASE PEOPLE LOOK AT HIS HEART ITS AS BIG AS ALL OUT DOORS , NOW DAYS WE NEED SOMEONE LIKE NATE HE WILL GIVE US SOMETHING MORE TO THINK ABOUT THAN THE WORLD AFFAIRS

    • liz said: On March 5, 2009

      i think if you have nothing nice to say you might want to keep your bad day comments to yourself
      at least he tried what have you done smart pants
      he is a good sole who has had a rough life who is trying to rise above and make something of himself
      then there are comments like yours that now he has to rise above even more
      so you have a nice day because your life must be just dandy

  15. Kelly said: On March 1, 2009

    Nate and my daughter went to high school together and became good friends. I love this kid. He really deserves to win this year! Good luck Nate! Make us proud!! You’ve put us on the map!!!

  16. joann said: On March 4, 2009

    hope you make it.

  17. LMFAO said: On March 5, 2009

    LMFAO… this kid is a FRUIT CAKE! He got dropped cuz he is lame. Period. I was raised in Malone (Go Huskies… sike), and I was shocked that he wasn’t some poor dumb redneck prison guard’s kid. He is so far at the other end of the loser spectrum that he is seriously touching “Boy George” status. LMFAO… nice headband. Now go get your Dale Jr. jacket!

    • Does LMFAO stand for LAME MOTHER F@$%&@ arrogant o-hole??????? Suits you well….. takes one boy george to know a boy george…and as for redneck prison guard at least they have a JOB to pay the bills welfare loser skank…

  18. megan said: On March 8, 2009

    omg i love you nate talk later love megan

  19. hi! i am trying to find nathaniels new address in burlington, vermont so that i can send him a check. if anyone knows it please send it to my e-mail thanks blix@verizonmail.com thanks

Leave a Reply